Friday Book Chats: Fictional Character Crushes

The first crush I remember having was on Robin Hood from the Disney animated movie of the same name. Yes, I am aware that he was a fox. I can’t explain why that didn’t seem weird at the time, but facts are facts. Falling hopelessly in love with fictional characters became something of a theme for me as I was growing up. Ok, ok…it’s still kind of a theme for me. Below is a list of my biggest book crushes, past and present.

See what I mean?

See what I mean? He’s, well, foxy. 😉

1. Gilbert Blythe from Anne of Green Gables. Gilbert Blythe who loves Anne Shirley from the moment she breaks her slate over his head. Who waits patiently for her to love him back. And then keeps loving her through babies and wars and all that comes with them. The recent death of actor Jonathan Crombie who played the role of Gilbert in the film version brought back so much nostalgia for this character and this series which I’ve read through at least 3 times.


2. Char (Prince Charmont) from Ella Enchanted. Don’t go off of the ridiculous movie version of this. The book is so, so much better. And Prince Charmont is sweet and charming and genuine enough to make any 12-year-old swoon. I liked him from the beginning, but after the scene where they slide down the banisters together I was a goner.


3. Paul from the Sierra Jensen series. Paul’s primary quality is that he is mysterious. As a teenager I was enchanted by that. Unlike Todd in the author’s previous books (the Christy Miller series), Paul was in and out. He was adventurous and moody and unpredictable and there was always real tension in the “will-they/won’t-they” of their relationship. Looking back on it, I can’t really say what was so likeable about Paul, but you get the impression from the first moment that you should be crazy about him.


4. Mr. Darcy from Pride and Prejudice. I think I could blame a lot of my teenage fantasies (and strange choices in real-life boy crushes) on Mr. Darcy. I wanted someone sort of brooding and mysterious – someone who seemed so stoic and distant to others, but who came alive for me. Lesson, ladies – when you are looking for this in a teenage boy, you are likely to find impressive amounts of angst and very little romance. Also, it is highly unlikely that anyone is going to look at you and say, “You have bewitched me body and soul,” unless you two are doing a P&P stage production together.

Mr. Darcy

5. Theodore Lawrence from Little Women – I admit, I always thought Jo was an idiot for not marrying Laurie. He’s got it all – he’s cultured and wealthy, but also kind and fun. He’s Jo’s best friend and they’ve grown up together and he adores her. What’s not to love?


Christian Bale before he was Batman.

6. Fred and George Weasley from Harry Potter. I know there are a lot more obvious choices here, but I just adore Fred and George. Plus I’ve always had a thing for red hair.


7. Peeta and Gale from The Hunger Games. Take your pick. There are things to love about both. For the record, I’m Team Peeta. Of course in the movies, Gale is more attractive, but looks aren’t everything and if you are going off of the books (which I am) I think Peeta is the clear winner.

Gale and Peeta

8. Aragorn son of Arathorn from Lord of the Rings. Because he’s a total bad-butt. (Which is how you say badass if you are Christian). And he’s got that whole steadfast love of Arwen over decades even though one would assume he could have his pick of the ladies. He is the kind of king who earns his crown and then looks good wearing it.


9. Kostas from Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. He’s the Greek fisherman who opens sweet, innocent Lena’s heart to love. And he’s got this fabulous accent.

Quatre filles et un jean The sisterhood of traveling pants 2005 Real : Ken Kwapis Michael Rady COLLECTION CHRISTOPHEL

10. Augustus Waters from The Fault in Our Stars. Allow me to quote Augustus:

“I’m in love with you, and I’m not in the business of denying myself the simple pleasure of saying true things. I’m in love with you, and I know that love is just a shout into the void, and that oblivion is inevitable, and that we’re all doomed and that there will come a day when all our labor has been returned to dust, and I know the sun will swallow the only earth we’ll ever have, and I am in love with you.” 

I think it’s self-explanatory why I (and every other girl in the world) love him. I melt.


I could go on, but I think I’ve exposed myself enough for one day. I know I’m not the only one to crush on fictional characters. Which characters have won your heart?


  1. I love these, especially Gilbert Blythe and Mr. Darcy! Mine was Rochester from Jane Eyre. I love his intense, brooding, Gothic passion, and I really love how he changes to a kind, humble man by the end of the novel. That proposal scene under the chestnut tree gets me EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. “I have a strange feeling with regard to you. As if I had a string somewhere under my left ribs, tightly knotted to a similar string in you. And if you were to leave I’m afraid that cord of communion would snap. And I have a notion that I’d take to bleeding inwardly.”


  2. Fun post!!! Yes, Gilbert Blythe, Aragorn, Augustus, and Peeta are some of my faves! Also, Jesse from Bridge to Terabithia (also played by Josh Hutcherson, in case you were wondering), Leo from A Ring of Endless Light, Calvin from A Wrinkle in Time, Park from Eleanor and Park, and Henry from The Time Traveler’s Wife.


    1. Henry from The Time Traveler’s Wife. Big fat sigh. Yes! Also agree with Park. Haven’t read the others in so long and I guess they didn’t make a huge impression the first time around for me.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. What fun! Everyone probably has that top 5/10 list of celebrities, but a fictional character list is much more romantic and whimsical. Is it weird that Professor Snape is on someone’s list? Asking for a (Potterhead) friend.


  4. PEETA! Peeta is my biggest literary crush of all time ever. But I’m also with ya on Laurie. And also I named my dog after Fred Weasley so…. I was a big fan of Minho in The Maze Runner. Not so much as the series went on but that’s a different blog post (one about diminishing returns in book series, the pressure to create quickly, and how exciting plot points can take the place of characterization). Also I read Ella Enchanted last year and WHAT THE HECK MOVIE. Book Prince Char is indeed charming.

    Given my propensity for both having crushes and reading books you think I’d have a long list of interests, but I have nothing to add here besides Minho, who I will always remember as the brave leader of the runners who listens to reason and works for common good with just a hint of sarcastic humor.


  5. What a great post
    before i share some of mine (which are very similar to yours go figure) i must tell you that RJG has written another book about sierra. you need to read. love finds you in sunset beach
    so gilbert, laurie(seriously jo), mr darcy, i loved paul but todd too, peeta, four (new one), marco


  6. Oh, Gilbert Blythe. Yes. I’m a little too removed age-wise from Peeta, it was all too teenage-angsty for me. Number one literary romantic crush for me is Jamie from Outlander. Jamie, Jamie, JAMIE. The end.


    1. Hahaha. I know that Jamie is a popular heartthrob. I just couldn’t get over him essentially spanking Claire that one time early on. Huge turn-off for me. But then again, I didn’t finish the series so he might have brought me around again if I’d stuck with it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s