Earned Grace – or That Time I Asked My Mom for a Spanking

There’s a story my parents used to tell about me as a child. I don’t remember exactly how old I was, but I remember where we lived at the time so I had to have been between 7 and 9. The story goes like this – one day, out of the blue, I came to my mom and told her I thought I needed a spanking. She asked why I thought that. Had I done something wrong? (She didn’t know of anything I’d done).

I told her I kept “thinking bad thoughts” and that I thought if I had a spanking they would go away. She was (understandably) a little baffled. But in our family, we were spanked for disobedience or bad attitudes. If I felt something was wrong in my heart, maybe a spanking would help me correct it. She’d never had something like this happen before and, not knowing what else to do, she reluctantly gave me a little spanking. After a few halfhearted licks with the paddle, she asked, “Do you feel better now?” And I told her, “I think I need a few more.”

My parents used to share this story (with my permission) in the Growing Kids God’s Way classes they taught at our church and school when I was in jr. high and high school. I didn’t attend the classes so I’m not sure what the context was for sharing it, but I can safely bet it was part of some discussion on spanking and discipline. At the time we all thought it was a kind of funny story that illustrated how kids know when they are out of control and how they crave discipline to help them gain control again. Also, I sort of liked this story because it made me feel like the best kid ever. What kid asks to be punished for something nobody knows they did? A perfect kid, that’s who! (That’s what I like to believe anyway).

As an adult I have a very different reaction to this story. As a child, I certainly didn’t understand everything I was feeling or what my motivations were. And even as a teenager, I was either not mature enough, or not distanced enough from that event to recognize those feelings. But now, when I remember that story, I cringe. Because I don’t just remember the story or what happened. I remember what it felt like. Now I understand that this was an early manifestation of something I’ve struggled with all of my life – the inability to accept grace without suffering or punishment.

I couldn’t articulate it at the time, but this is what was happening in my mind and heart that day. For some reason, curse words had starting popping into my head. I was a child, so they weren’t really connected to particular situations – I wasn’t thinking them in moments of frustration or anger. I was simply thinking them. A stream of curse words running through my head while I was playing. I knew this was wrong and I felt guilty, but I couldn’t figure out how to make it stop. I apologized to God over and over, but I couldn’t seem to stop doing it.

I didn’t get spanked often growing up. Apart from one year when I was 4 and decided to be a holy terror, I got spanked a few times a year on average. It was the standard discipline in our home for anything that fell under the category of rebellion and I have 3 siblings, so it wasn’t unusual for someone to get spanked, but I was pretty well behaved after that one bad year and didn’t act out very often. I didn’t know whether it was because the result was restored relationship with my parents or because it represented repentance in my heart or simply because of the catharsis of a good cry, but I knew that I felt better after a spanking.

So at this point, I was feeling horrible guilt and shame about all of these curse words in my head. I knew I was doing something wrong. And the only thing I could think of that might make me feel better was a spanking. See, I strongly correlated forgiveness with punishment. In my mind, forgiveness wasn’t just the thing that followed punishment. It was actually produced by punishment. In other words, I did not believe that I could have forgiveness or experience grace unless I had experienced punishment.

Punishment and consequences aren’t the same thing. Consequences are the natural and unchangeable result of a certain actions. Punishment is “suffering, pain, or loss that serves as retribution.” Grace doesn’t remove consequences. It removes guilt and shame. It removes the need for punishment or penance.

What I was doing was trying to use punishment to remove guilt. This is dangerous thinking. This is the child’s version of the “mortification of the flesh” that has led some to self-flagellation. This is believing we have to earn love and forgiveness—either through good actions or through suffering. And that isn’t the story of Christianity.

I want to take a moment to say that I do not blame my parents for this in any way. I firmly believe that if they had understood what was going on inside of me they wouldn’t have spanked me – and they certainly wouldn’t have told the story later. But they were still new in their faith and learning to be parents and certainly there was no textbook answer to this situation. This post isn’t about spanking. I’m not here to debate whether parents should spank their children or not, so please don’t get side-tracked by the details. This is about grace and about my inability to accept it.

The feeling I had that day has come up many times since. I was 17 when I got my driver’s license. I was a nervous driver – always afraid of making a mistake – afraid to be in control of something as powerful as that engine wrapped in steel and glass. I didn’t trust myself with it. Ironically, I got into an accident that totaled my mom’s car the very first day I drove it by myself.

The thing that stood out most to me that day and in the weeks that followed was how NOT angry my parents were. I wanted them to yell at me, to tell me they were disappointed, to punish me in some way. Instead they were just happy that I was OK.  They knew I wasn’t being careless, I was just inexperienced and I had an accident. I didn’t need correction or discipline. I needed more confidence.

But I was plagued with guilt – the kind of guilt that makes you feel sick in the pit of your stomach. No one was making me feel bad or holding it over my head, but I was filled with an overwhelming sense of shame. I had screwed up and I had a hard accepting that I was completely forgiven and unconditionally loved.

Why is it so hard to accept grace? And why is it so much easier to extend grace to others than to ourselves?

Now that I’m an adult, I understand this part of myself. I see it in my marriage. When I really mess up, my husband forgives me and moves on like it never happened. And I catch myself thinking “I’ll make his favorite dinner and do all the chores this weekend and I won’t ask him to help with anything, and I’ll iron those shirts I keep forgetting about, and I’ll wear the sexy undies even though they are really uncomfortable, and I’ll give him a lot of compliments.” Of course, these can be great ways to show love to my husband. But not when I’m doing them as self-inflicted penance.

I can’t seem to wrap my mind around a grace that is unearned or forgiveness that comes punishment-free. Believe me, I’ve spent a lot of time trying. But I had a moment of epiphany recently. Maybe I can’t wrap my mind around it because I’m not supposed to.

Maybe I am not supposed to understand unearned grace because grace didn’t come free. Grace came at the price of Love’s only son, stretched out on a tree. Maybe I’m not supposed to embrace a forgiveness that comes without suffering because Love did suffer.

Maybe my problem isn’t that I think grace and forgiveness cost something. Maybe my problem is accepting who it cost. Maybe my problem is that I can’t wrap my mind around, “It is finished.”


“Because the sinless savior died

My sinful soul was counted free

For God the just was satisfied

To look on Him and pardon me.”

My sister sang this song at our wedding. I wish I had a recording of her singing it to share, but I really like this arrangement too.



  1. Thank you for sharing! I can’t tell you how many times I have asked for forgiveness and yet continue to beat myself up over my mistakes rather than accepting the forgiveness the Lord has given me. I have a similar thought process when it comes to forgiveness from my husband, he will forgive me and move on and not give my mistake another thought and yet I will make a list in my head of things I can try and do to “earn” his forgiveness (ex: bake him goodies, watch his tv shows with him, or go the extra effort of looking nice for him….) rather than just do these things because I love him there is a shred of wanting to free myself of my guilt. It is nice to know other people share my struggles. 🙂


    1. Ahh, I understand EXACTLY what you mean. I’m so glad you could identify with this. I think it’s a constant struggle to just allow God’s grace to be sufficient. I would love to move past this some day, but I have a feeling it’s going to be something I wrestle with throughout my life. Thanks so much for sharing. 🙂


  2. Very interesting. Oh and Welcome to Columbia, SC. I live over near South Congaree and Gaston on the South West Side of town where 26 and 77 meet.


  3. It’s interesting how different people feel & react. Especially these days to do with spanking. I was on the whole a pretty good kid. I think I had pretty good parents too. In my free time, I was free to roam the neighborhood with my friends. There was no requirement to let them know or ask permission for where I went.

    I occasionally was spanked. A few times per year. Somewhere along the way it became the cane. Always over my pants. I actually never felt humiliated by the punishment but I did bad that I had done whatever I was being punished for. I also began to feel a sense of relief at being caught and punished. Maybe because I always felt loved by my parents and also I don’t think I was ever punished for anything I wasn’t actually guilty of. Also I don’t recall ever having misbehavior revisited. Once punished it was never spoken of again.

    Our family attended church sposmadically. Enough though for me to hear messages about repentance, forgiveness, love and so on.

    Anyway one day in junior high, prob around 14, my friends and I ganged up on this kid and made life hell for him. We’d steal his pencil and his homework. Trip him and bump into him and so on. I was feeling bad but also wanted tobe a part of my group so went along with it. Eventually, thankfully, the teachers worked out what was going on. We were all taken aside and talked to and given a detention where we had to write some essays about what it felt like to be the bully and why we’d done it and also what it was like to be the victim.

    I felt like crap. I agonised and chewed over it and still felt dejected. Disappointed in myself. Gutless for just going along with it.

    It kept eating me and one day I told my parents. We had a long discussion. My recollection is that their first response was the schools delt with it. I remember taking a deep breath and saying that I thought I should be punished. The discussing continued and I think my point was I understood better how the victim felt like I had repented but I had not been punished. They asked what I thought was a suitable punishment, I with some hesitation said the cane, the rod of correction. Like in the Bible.

    I received that cane and it hurt like hell. Much more than I remember it hurting before. I was allowed to go to my room and cry. I also recall an almost immediate calmness. It really felt like this cleansing wash over me.

    When I came out of my room, I got another shock. I was used to things never being mentioned again. My parents said that I must go over to this boys place and apologise and to invite him over to play. I was mortified. This was far worse than the caning. We got in the car and went. I had to knock on the door and infront of all the parents apologize.

    The best bit was that we became friends.

    So I guess I don’t see the idea of earned grace. Somone gives you grace. I’m stuggling to express my thoughts. It’s something like there are different people affected when you do something wrong. The victim is only one person. They can give you grace but I don’t think they can punish. That is retribution. I think punish is more for the purportrators benefit. Cleansing somehow. Also a bit like forgiveness by the victim is necessary for the victim to stop feeling resentment.


    1. Thanks for sharing your story. I believe that different people can have different reactions to similar experiences. I don’t think it was wrong for me to be punished when I did something wrong, or even that spanking is necessarily wrong. Im just now realizing that for me, being punished wasn’t about being cleansed. It was the thing that made me worthy of grace. So for me, it would have been better to have understood that the grace was there whether or not I was punished. Especially sine the thing I was being punished for was merely bad words inside my head. I hadn’t done anything to anyone else. Amnother reason that I feel this wasn’t a helpful punishment for me is that I remember my spankings, but for the most part, I don’t remember what I did wrong to deserve them. I remember the shame of being punished, but I don’t remember what I did to earn the punishment or what I learned from it. I truly believe that different children learn and respond differently and I would never say that my experience is true for everyone, but it was true for me and it’s something I’m still working to unlearn. It sounds like you had very loving and engaged parents and I appreciate your story. I’m sure there are others here who can relate. Thanks for reading and thanks for offering your thoughts!


      1. Hi Lilyelln,
        Thanks for your considered reply. Yes loving parents. Like you mostly I do not remember what the misdeed was that resulted in the punishment. A few memorable ones but on the whole no recollection. A bit like sweeping generalisations really. No feelings of ever being punished for something I did not do.

        Just thinking about your journey, one thing I picked up was that in your original post you said

        “she reluctantly gave me a little spanking. After a few halfhearted licks with the paddle, she asked, “Do you feel better now?” And I told her, “I think I need a few more.” ”

        It seems to me that your mom had the situation under control.


  4. Ok, you are very completely confused. Not completely accepting unearned grace is the shurest way to grow farther apart from the lord. You NEED to embrace the forgiveness of the lord! Yes he suffered, but he suffered for YOU, so would you actually not embrace complete forgiveness?

    Your obsession with punishment is a phychological problem. Accept the lord’s grace and forgiveness, or you will never be close to him.

    You can’t, won’t, and haven’t earned your salvation. But god loved you enough to send down his son to save you.

    Will you really reject the lord’s full forgiveness and unbridled love because of guilt?

    Jesus CHOSE to suffer to save our soles, don’t make you yourself hidden from him for foolishness.

    EMBRACE his love.


    1. I’m not sure you understood this post. You are right. I was completely confused about this as a child. That’s the whole point of this post. That when I was a child I thought I had to earn grace and couldn’t be forgiven without punishment. Now, as an adult, I understand that that’s wrong and that it distorted my understanding of God and his goodness.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s